East Versus West

 

Which is Better?

People new to Georgetown are often surprised to come across the insular terms East Village and West Village. They are terms used to distinguish those parts of Georgetown on either side of Wisconsin Ave. Beyond simple geography, these terms often carry with them loaded associations, most of which are unjustified in GM’s opinion. So what’s the deal with the two villages?

The first issue to address when talking about these terms is where exactly they came from. The initial thought most people likely have is that the names are just copies of the Manhattan neighborhood names. It would not be the first time a neighborhood looked to steal a little cache from New York (although, the pre-gentrified East Village of New York is hardly the type of neighborhood that the East Village of Georgetown has ever aspired to be).

It’s not clear from a search through the Washington Post archives whether copying New York is the source of the names. However, it does appear that the names are really not that old. GM couldn’t find a use of the term before 1986, and even then it was just in a real estate listing. This shouldn’t be a surprise. The names are more creatures of real estate listings than they are actively used in everyday conversation.

Beyond real estate listings, the names appeared only a few times in the Post throughout the 80’s and 90’s. It’s not until this last decade or so that the terms began to be accepted for normal article-use. Perhaps what opened the floodgates was this piece from just a few years ago, which was apparently the first time the newspaper ever discussed the names at any depth.

While the post article doesn’t perform much of an etymological survey, it does discuss the supposed cultural history of the two quarters. It states that legend has it that the “split” between the villages can be traced to the decision on the part of some rich Episcopals to quit St. John’s on the west side and establish Christ Church on the east side (a bit more genteel form of schism than Episcopals are used to these days).  Sounds a bit apocryphal to GM.

So which side is better? Here’s GM’s head-to-head (with the advantage in bold):

                                                             East Village                                 West Village                         

Most expensive home:            Everymay $50 m.               Halcyon House $30 m           

Current Politicians:                  Roy Blunt                                     John Kerry
                                                                                                                   Max Baucus             

Past Politicians:                         Allen Dulles                                JFK’s house when 
                                                          Robert Taft                                  elected president
                                                          Joe Kennedy
                                                          Alger Hiss
                                                         JFK’s house when 
                                                               congressman

Journalists:                                Bob Woodward                       Maureen Dowd
                                                        George Stephanopolous
                                                        Ben Bradlee
                                                        Sally Quinn

Parks:                                           Montrose Park                        Volta Park
                                                        Rose Park
                                                        Dumbarton Oaks Park

In GM’s opinion, the East Village has “grander” homes, is a bit quieter, and has none of the West Village’s traffic problems. On the other hand, the West Village has homes that rate higher on the “quaintness” scale, more neighborhood stores, and Volta Park pool.  In the end, GM is happy to live in the East Village, but the differences are probably overblown.

So what do you think? Is one side better than the other or are the terms just useless parochialism?

Advertisements

4 Comments

Filed under Around Town

4 responses to “East Versus West

  1. J. MacLeod Carter

    I really enjoyed that article – and think the whole East/West thing was indeed invented by Realtors. I always laugh when I see a Realtor’s listing point out that such-and-such a property is located in the “prestigious East Village.” I assume all the homes in the East Village have “grand foi-yeahs” (meaning 3 by 4 feet) and “spacious gourmet kitchens” (usually meaning galley-sized). Realtor speak is ridicules!

  2. GM

    The funny thing is that one of the common threads of Washington Post articles about the East Village is that Nancy Taylor Bubes seems to get quoted pretty often in them.

    And who was the one of the first real estate brokers to start using the term “East Village” back around 1986? A certain broker named “Nancy Taylor”.

    Is NTB behind the whole thing?

  3. jkc

    Everyone worth their salt knows the West Village is better. Don’t be jealous, East Villagers.

  4. Pingback: Head West, Young Man | The Georgetown Metropolitan

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s